Indigo Creek 214 Rome School Rd, Middletown, NY Overview

3.2-acre picturesque waterfront setting on the site of Indigot Creek’s Gristmill adjacent to acres of undeveloped mountain woodlands. Resident wildlife watching from most windows and large waterfront deck, gardening, hiking, fishing, hunting. Secluded permanent home or weekend retreat from commutable urban work centers. Complete separate in-law or rentable living apartment. Upgraded, move-in ready, one-floor living with 5-car-off- and 5-car on-street parking. Tile and hardwood flooring, quiet country setting close to year-round recreation, public parks, shopping, entertainment, worship. Once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

The ultimate private seclusion with magnificent waterfront and mountain views from most rooms and all decks. 4-bed, 3-bath custom-built home next to Indigot Creek on the site of a former water mill with three lots totaling 3.2 mostly-wooded acres. Permanent home or resort retreat. Upgraded, move-in ready, one-floor living plus separate extended-family quarters with 5-car-off- and 5-car on-street parking. Tile and hardwood flooring, quiet country surroundings close to year-round recreation, public parks, shopping, entertainment, worship. Once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

Indigo Creek 214 Rome School Rd, Middletown, NY Features

SETTING: Secluded, Historical, Grist Mill and stream on 3.2 wooded acres with mountain side and Indigot Creek on property.

INTERIOR: 4-bed, 3-bath, fully renovated, one-floor living, dual kitchens, in-law quarters, wood-burning fireplace

EXTERIOR: Large deck beside the creek, garage/work shop, 5-car off-street & 5-car on-street parking, Garden, Hiking, fishing, hunting

APPLIANCES: Dish Washer, Microwave, Gas Range, Smoke & CO

UTILITIES: Well, Septic, Oil Baseboard Heat, Air Conditioning

Southern Orange County, NY

Warwick, Middletown, Centerville

Southern Orange County, NY, Real Estate, Lifestyle Overview and Homes for Sale

Southern Orange County, NY General Description

Market Conditions

  • Strong lifestyle-driven demand
  • Limited new construction
  • High appeal to NYC buyers

Southern Orange County, NY Real Estate and Housing Market

Home Styles & Architecture

  • Colonial and Center Hall Colonials
  • Cape Cods and expanded ranches
  • Contemporary and chalet-style homes near resort areas
  • Historic farmhouses and stone homes (Lafayette & Wantage)
  • Townhomes and condominiums in Vernon and Hardyston resort zones
  • Most homes were built between the 1960s and early 2000s, with select newer communities.

 

Housing Types & Density

  • Predominantly single-family detached homes
  • Moderate-to-low housing density
  • Concentrated condo and townhome developments in Vernon & Hardyston

 

Northeast Sussex County NJ Home Prices

  • Typical price range: $325,000 – $700,000+
  • Entry-level condos/townhomes: $200,000 – $350,000
  • Lakefront, view, or acreage properties command premium pricing
  • Overall, the market is considered mid-range to upper-mid-range, offering strong value relative to Morris, Bergen, or Passaic Counties.

Southern Orange County, NY Market Conditions

Market Conditions

  • Strong lifestyle-driven demand
  • Limited new construction
  • High appeal to NYC buyers

Southern Orange County, NY Healthcare and Medical Access

Nearby, renowned regional hospitals that provide the network of medical services needed in the New Jersey Gold Coast area include:

  • Middletown Hospital
  • Morristown Medical Center (Atlantic health System)

Southern Orange County, NY Transportation and Commuting

Transportation

  • Metro-North & NJ Transit (Port Jervis Line)
  • Route 17, NY Thruway
  • Commute: 75–90 minutes to NYC

Southern Orange County, NY Statistical Profile

Community Profile

  • Population: ~75,000 (combined)
  • Median household income: $85,000 – $100,000
  • Household type: Predominantly owner-occupied
  • Average household size: ~2.6

Southern Orange County, NY Lifestyle, Dining and Entertainment

The Appalachian at Mountain Creek is an All-Season Mountain & Adventure Resort with a Slope-side lodging resort base

This resort hotel is located at the Mountain Creek Resort in northeastern Sussex County and blending adventure with convenience and comfort—all within the scenic Vernon Valley region.

The Mountain Creek Resort is a premier outdoor activity center offering:

  • Winter Sports: Extensive skiing and snowboarding with well-maintained trails and lifts.
  • Summer Fun: Seasonal water parks, water slides, mountain biking parks, and aerial adventure/ziplines.
  • Year-Round Events: Zip lines, alpine coaster thrills, seasonal festivals, and family adventures.
James Bean Professional Portrait and Coldwell Banker Global Luxury Logo.

James Bean

Listing Broker

(973) 987-7065

beanjc@gmail.com

I would like:









Franklin Lakes, NJ

James’ multi-faceted talents enable him to be effective across a very broad span of real estate issues. His background includes experience and expertise in Construction, Professional Photography, Project Management, Marketing and Information Technology! I enthusiastically recommend James Bean to anyone seeking the services of a top-notch real estate agent.

Grand New Homes

Luxurious living, upscale amenities, secluded, natural settings in fine new or established communities.
Find It Now

Greenwood Lake, NJ

Thank you, James! Multiple previous agents who gave very little attention, advice or service left us stalled about what to do next. James engaged and impressed us with his positive vision from the very first meeting. James’ open houses are successful and produce qualified buyers! Thank you for your tenacity and persevering level of energy! James went beyond our expectations and we will always be grateful!

Grand New Homes Discriminating LIfestyles

These beautiful areas are filled with high-value homes in exceptional settings that will make you feel as though you are on a perpetual vacation. .
Find It Now

West Milford, NJ

We especially appreciate your dedication and hard work: negotiating the contract, finding a good lender, finding an inspector, maintaining progress while we were out of state and taking the time to go over all the details of getting us settled.

Grand New Homes Exceptional Homes

Work with professionals experienced at finding these magnificent country retreats.
Find It Now

Hudson River, NJ

James remained patient and gave me good advice along the way. We made a number of wise adjustments and reached my goals. Most importantly, my home sold for more than my prior agents thought possible!

Grand New Homes Exceptional Lifestyles

Superior work and earning opportunities within commuting distance of resort living and recreational venues.
Find It Now

Stay In Touch!
















M - (973) 987-7065

James Bean

beanjc@gmail.com

 Primary Office:  Coldwell Banker Realty       24 White Deer Pl, Sparta, NJ 07871       Office: (973) 222-6521

© 2026 Copyright 2026 by James Bean